Recent Film Reviews
Old Film Reviews
Navigation

The new album from Al Rose. Available at CD Baby,  iTunes and Amazon.

If you like the cut of our jib over here at The Moving World, please consider kicking a little something our way.

Journal Archive
« Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows--Part 2 | Main | The Trip »
Tuesday
Jul242012

Tabloid

    

Here's the latest from Errol Morris, one of the foremost documentarians of our time.  He's given us, among others, "The Thin Blue Line," which freed a man wrongly convicted of murder and got the guilty man locked up; the deeply moving "Gates of Heaven," which only seemed to be about pet cemeteries (its real subject, in Roger Ebert’s words, was “the central mystery of life”) and "Fast, Cheap & Out of Control," which we took my young stepdaughter to see more than a decade ago.  (It turned out to work quite well as a kid's movie.)  A few years ago he gave us a portrait of Vietnam War architect Robert McNamara (the fascinating "Fog of War").  That's all well and good, but now he brings us a story that has the kind of stuff people are really interested in: sex and bad behavior.

I knew nothing about Joyce McKinney when I went into the picture.  Her story is one of the most bizaare you're likely to hear, and it just keeps getting weirder.  Joyce herself is one of the funniest, saddest characters I've encountered in movies in recent memory.  When we first meet her, in footage from the early 80s, she looks like a princess.  That's fitting: she seems to imagine herself as a princess in a fairy tale.  She's even reading from a storybook, her own manuscript telling in her own words the tale that had so delighted Britain just a few years earlier: how the princess met her Prince Charming, only to have him spirited away from her by dark forces.  The young Joyce exudes sweet innocence with her farm-girl accent; at the same time she glows with a kind of warm, sleepy, sated sexuality.  Then we see talking-head interviews with the Joyce of today, a woman of 60 who still exhibits the same spirit and smile. 

As a young beauty queen (a former Miss Wyoming World) McKinney landed in Salt Lake City and, for some inexplicable reason, fell in love virtually at first sight with an unassuming, heavyset Mormon missionary called Kirk Anderson.  What did it for her, in her memorable phrase, was his "clean skin".  (Anderson refused to participate with this film).  When the church removed him to England, she hired a pilot and, along with some male hangers-on, tracked him down.  (Joyce was always in the company of men who were obsessed with her to the same extent that she only had eyes for Kirk). 

What happens next depends on to whose story you believe.  According to Joyce, Kirk went away with her willingly.  They repaired to a cottage in Devon.  She admits that she tied him to the bed, having read that a little bondage is the way to dispel psychological impotence. 

(Morris interviews an ex-member/whistleblower on the sexual repression of the Mormon church: he discusses, among other things, the "chastity suits" they make you wear.  In fact one of McKinney's issues with this film is that it doesn't focus much more on the Mormons as a “cult”; she has plenty to say on the church’s evils, such as inculcating people with guilt and shame about the God-given pleasures of sex.  It strikes me that as an avowed Christian she’s on rather shaky ground here.)  

In her narrative they proceeded to have three wonderful days of sex and food and togetherness.  The other story, the one trumpeted in the tabloids throughout Britain in 1977, is that she kidnapped him with the aid of chloroform, hired heavies and a very real-looking fake gun, "CHAINED" him to a bed "SPREAD EAGLED" and raped him for three days.  (Morris blows these words and others up onto the screen into huge, tabloid headlines.  Film theorist James Monaco has written that cinema "raises fundamental questions about the relationship of life and art, reality and language," and it strikes me that this movie offers a full course on that idea.) 

The fact that the "victim" here was a man makes the accusations of kidnapping and rape not exactly funny, perhaps, but...unusual.  The question arises of whether it's even possible for a woman to rape a man.  Joyce thinks rather not (she has a brilliant line which I shall let you discover for yourself).  I am inclined to agree with her, if I’m honest.

After a brief pre-trial tenure in Epsom prison, the star of “the Mormon sex in chains case," the “Case of the Manacled Mormon," proceeded to cut a swath through late-70s celebrity culture in Britain, briefly outshining even the hottest movie stars of the time.  Keith Moon was photographed giving her a smacker.  The tabloids began looking into her background; The Daily Mirror dug up photos documenting what seemed to be a past life as a S&M hooker (forgeries, she claims).  There ensued a sort of competing-narratives war with Britain's other best-selling tabloid, The Daily Express, each telling different versions of her story.  

    (The movie is also about the ruthlessly aggressive tabloid culture in England.  It had the good fortune to be released at the time of the shuttering of "News of the World" and the phone-hacking scandal exposing the cozy relationship between Rupert Murdoch's NewsCorp/News International and the top of Britain's government and police force.  Not to mention in the wake of the Casey Anthony verdict, the ultimate tabloid case.  This story is of course exponentially lighter in tone than all of that)

As it happens, McKinney never finished writing her story herself, and now Errol Morris has done his version.  He is a great storyteller.  This movie is not investigative journalism: Morris is not interested in "getting to the bottom” of McKinney’s story.  He's interested in the mystery of the narrative, in reflecting it in as many facets as possible.  After all, as I once heard Christopher Hitchens put it, "The truth never lies, but when it does lie it lies somewhere in between."  

The competing narratives are one of the fascinating things about the movie.  Actually, it's now spilled off-screen.  The subject of the story isn't being quiet.  McKinney has her own idea about what kind of story this is, and she wants to tell it her way.  She for one does not see the humor in it.  This is not a sex comedy to her, it’s "tragic and intellectual".  McKinney is in many ways the perfect Morris subject; his films are always about obsession on some level.  (Filmmaking itself is obsessive.)  The problem is that the man who trades in ironies has finally met a woman quite without any sense of irony whatsoever.  She can claim, in all sincerity, to have never wanted anything more from life than a "little Leave-It-to-Beaver house with a white picket fence."  (Among other thing, the film is a fount of great lines.)

To Morris’ bemusement, she's apparently been attending more festival screenings of the film than he himself has, decrying the film and trying to get her side of the story out.  She says she intends to sue.  [Check out the video of her appearance at a New York screening.  I admire how at no point does Morris try to silence her.  Note her maniacal laugh at the end.]

      It would be wrong to understate the extent to which McKinney is herself an actress, so to speak.  She loved assuming new identities with her main partner in crime (a fellow called Keith May, now deceased), dressing up with him as an Indian couple, or even a pair of nuns, eluding arrest and obtaining fake passports to get back into the U.S.  She's a very shrewd manipulator, but never a malign one.  You can see it in the photos from the time: that radiant smile.  There's never a trace of shame.  She's got Bettie Page's ability to exude such pleasure in being naked that even the S&M shots that turn up never really seem tawdry.  

 I like how Morris doesn't condescend to tabloids.  You can tell that he actually gets a kick out of them.  He invigorates the movie with that same pulpy, exploitive quality, both in its look and in the way it tells its story.  "I am no different than any of the men in this story," he's said: obsessed with JoyceThere is a bit of a feeling of taking glee in a situation in which someone may have been hurt, but I suppose that’s part of what people enjoy about tabloids themselves.  (You have to be completely non-moralistic to enjoy them; I suppose at some level there's still vestiges of a tut-tutting leftist in me who believes that the masses would be much better off if they were picking up, say, Chomsky pamphlets on the way out of Jewel instead of these rags.) 

 

 

Re-reading Roger Ebert’s review of Morris’ “Gates of Heaven”, it struck me how relevant it was to my thinking about this film.  "Heaven" is one of Ebert’s favorite movies, a film about pet cemeteries and the bond between animals and humans (often eccentric ones).  He writes that “Heaven” became “a litmus test for audiences, who cannot decide if it is serious or satirical, funny or sad, sympathetic or mocking.”  Much the same is true here.  The audience I was with laughed long and hard, and so did I at times.  However, some other words from Ebert’s review of “Heaven” speak to me:     

“The signs on the pet markers are eloquent in their way.  ‘I knew love; I knew this dog.’ ‘Dog is God spelled backwards.’  ‘For saving my life.’  At the end of the film, having laughed earlier, we find ourselves silent. These animal lovers are expressing the deepest of human needs, for love and companionship.”

When asked late in the film if she still loves Kirk to this day, McKinney replies, tears welling up in her eyes, that she still does and that she always will.  That much I believe is true.  The part I wasn't laughing at. 

   

And hey, she loves dogs, too.  I didn't even touch on the pit-bull cloning.  That I will leave you to discover for yourself.  (I told you the story just kept getting wierder.) 

Rating: **** 

-- July 17, 2011

 
Key to ratings:

***** (essential viewing)
**** (excellent)
*** (worth a look)
** (forgettable)
* (rubbish!!)

 

 

 

 

 

 

References (105)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    Response: nike free run 3
    Check out at least a couple of vacation rental agencies.
  • Response
    Response: VmeWiTwn
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    Response: uggs à vendre
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    Response: moncler sale
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    NFL is seriously one of the biggest sports in America. It has a important following.
  • Response
    I want to start my own blog: are there such thing as blogs that are totally "open", and anybody can view it? I keep coming to the kind where you have to add other "friends" to use the site. . Links appreciated. Thanks!.
  • Response
    Response: insolvency advice
    I'm finding them for my sister. I'm trying to find the most recipes with pictures and the ages of baby for the recipes. Blogs are usually where I would expect to find them..
  • Response
    A) it is acceptable to use copyrighted material for economic gain as long as proper credit is given to the author.. . B) all original work located on the Internet is to be considered copyrighted.. . C) only items marked with the ? symbol are considered copyrighted.. . D) all Internet ...
  • Response
    Response: organic seo
    How do you prevent content from being removed on youtube due to copyright?
  • Response
    Response: seo firm
    I wanted to start my own blog and I was looking for your suggestions for which sites you think are the best to start one with. . I want to be able to post pictures, text, and music (maybe).. I only want to use a free blog host..
  • Response
    Does anyone know how you get those customised backgrounds on wordpress. All i can seem to get is the ones they provide. Can someone help me pleaseeeeeeeeeee?.
  • Response
    A computer starts somewhere. It starts with a bios and a CPU and a motherboard ect... When we code that computer to pump out a random number, what makes it pick the number it picks? Exactly the same computer sits beside it's identical and they both pick different 1st random numbers. ...
  • Response
    Response: discount pet meds
    I stored a library account number and had to renew the card. How do I now eliminate the old account number from the Firefox memory?. Thanks!.
  • Response
    Response: sem services
    I need a computer program that will automatically start another program and not let that program close for a work computer. So basically, when the computer starts up, this program I am looking for will start a work-related program and force it to stay open, so that the only use of ...
  • Response
    I would like to remove the blogger and designer links on the attribution bar at the bottom of a blogger page. I know its not good to remove it and usually i don't, but this is a page for a business so it needs to look clean and profesisonal..
  • Response
    How come my computer does not register the other computers in the network?
  • Response
    How to use mozila firefox seting from an other windows?
  • Response
    Response: web design
    Firefox wont start but when I open a link that opens firefox, It works fine. What do I do?
  • Response
    So I just made a blogspot about SNSD. I dont really know how to let other people know about the blogspot, like you know famous? But not the real famous glamorous type. Because I really want to maintain the site but thats kinda tiring if you keep on posting stuffs if ...
  • Response
    I want to start a website for my Roller derby team, all we have is a myspace right now. How can I start a website that has a dot com, or html, etc, that I can design on my own, and keep up on my own so that we can actually ...
  • Response
    Response: traditional ira
    What is the easiest way to get updates from my subscribed blogs?
  • Response
    Response: certified psychics
    I am struggling with this problem, unknowingly i started importing other person blog posts..............which i want to disable. Please help me out.
  • Response
    Response: roof hatch
    I am starting a business during the summer where I work with kids individually or during a camp. I was wondering how I could start a website for my clients parents to look at during the summer..
  • Response
    Response: bullion investment
    I really love to write and I'm pretty good at it. But whenever I try to write a story or something I start off good but always end up throwing it away--I can never seem to finish it. . . Sometimes I have a good idea that I really like but ...
  • Response
    How do Microsoft and the owners of Firefox make money? Google is planning to create a browser also to compete with them called "chrome". I was wondering where does the source of revenue come in? There are no ads, etc. These programs are free..
  • Response
    Response: gold price
    Is there free software or online database to keep track of scheduled blog posts? I would also like it to keep a record of past and future posts. I am trying to avoid creating a spreadsheet in Excel..
  • Response
    Response: acne scars
    Can I copyright 20 pages of old newspaper articles ?
  • Response
    Response: cool training
    What are the norms of copyright of web content? How's it different from Patent?
  • Response
    Response: insurance claims
    I want to build a blog in wordpress where I can share photos, have people upload photos and everyone can rate them. Can anybody recommend a good theme or some tips? Free is preferred or like, under $100.. . Thanks!.
  • Response
    I have been a yahoo users for some years now. I am only starting to make use of the tools which they provide, one of which being blog posts. I have written a blog and would like to know if my blog posts are being seen by others. If not then ...
  • Response
    Response: here
    How can you tell if a video has copyright content or not?.
  • Response
    How hard is it to import a custom made Joomla template into Joomla?
  • Response
    I would like to setup wordpress blog that would allow people to sign up to receive news letters and updates? Do I need to download wordpress to my computer? Is there any pre-made templates for this type?.
  • Response
    How does a computer virus getting formed?. I have a lot of computer viruses lately but thanks to Norton Anti-virus and Malwarebytes Anti-malware my computer is 100% secure. But how does a computer virus formed? Do people actually make it and they spread it throughout the internet?. . Please tell me ...
  • Response
    Response: this
    What are the best colleges for creative writing and screenwriting?
  • Response
    How can I change to fluid width in the New Blogger Template Designer?
  • Response
    Response: hosting seo
    see here for greatest increase traffic work available
  • Response
    I have had Firefox, IE, and Google chrome downloaded onto my computer for a while now with no problem. Recently I downloaded YIM and now Firefox doesn't start up. If I restart my computer a few times, and try to open it a few dozen times each time I restart, it ...
  • Response
    Wonderful thoughts
  • Response
    Response: visit our website
    How can I find cheap, reliable wordpress web designers that I can out source my webdesign work to?
  • Response
    Response: Window Repair
    It seems there are websites and blogs devoted to many activities, such tv, music, lives of celebrities, etc.. . But I really cannot find websites and blogs devoted to reading, unfortunately an afterthought when it comes to pastimes.. . Anyone know some really popular and great ones? Classic and current literature ...
  • Response
    I have heard of blogs and kind of know what they are. My question is what do you write on a blog, like stuff thats on your mind or just whatever? And what websites can i logon to to start blogs?.
  • Response
    Response: my company
    I'm trying to find out what the most popular blogs are when it comes to news and views and cell phone stuff..
  • Response
    This made me snigger for a long time.
  • Response
    How do I setup my computer to automatically update folders onto a removable drive upon insertion?
  • Response
    I want to be able to customize a wordpress themes to make them look a bit more origional. I know you can change the colors, etc. But i want to be able to change the size of the boxes and such. I like iblog and am looking for something similar but ...
  • Response
    Response: seo market
    go here for greatest seo origin work available
  • Response
    Response: focus
    go here for the top new cars kansas city available
  • Response
    How do I change firefox from remembering my facebook info?
  • Response
    I want to put the advertisements in blogger, so I can get payments?.
  • Response
    I know many wikipedia articles contains copyright violation or licence violation. how do i do this..
  • Response
    Response: more bonuses
    What is the best blogging platform for a podcast or a video blog?
  • Response
    I have a small background in magazine journalism but my new job requires no writing at all, except for emails. . . I would like to start doing some creative writing but I don't know where to start, as in, what do I write about, and whether it's actually worth bothering ...
  • Response
    Response: web link
    I am not experienced with joomla but I want to use to make a website. My only trouble right now is getting it installed on Yahoo hosting I don't know what to do.. . Can anyone direct me to a site or forum for this or tell me how do it? ...
  • Response
    Response: click for more
    I really love to write and I'm pretty good at it. But whenever I try to write a story or something I start off good but always end up throwing it away--I can never seem to finish it. . . Sometimes I have a good idea that I really like but ...
  • Response
    Response: read more here
    Where can I find free images?. Which images are usually considered free?. When is it ok to insert a picture from a website?.
  • Response
    The top quality posicionamiento web seo anywhere
  • Response
    I am 15 and I want to start a fashion blog. What should I call it? Also, please tell me any tips you have for getting started and what I could do on it or how to do it..
  • Response
    My friend wants to read a story I wrote in a video on her Youtube channel. I'm concerned that my story could be stolen by some one, and have them claim it as their own, not that I think it's really good enough for anyone to want to steal it. How ...
  • Response
    Response: index
    I want to be able to use my gmail account to forward blog posts to people, but for some reason Thunderbird keeps forcing me to use my college e-mail. Is there a way to change this?.
  • Response
    Response: Dev Panic Advice
    Where are some good places to get good free blogger templates?
  • Response
    What is the easiest way to add a blog to my existing website?
  • Response
    avec telephone, code reduction pour forfait sosh,
  • Response
    cliquez sur code reduction sosh juin 2013, code re
  • Response
    Response: click here now
    Any suggestions on sites to start a blog where I can BS sports and another happenings?
  • Response
    So I created a secondary blog off my first one, but I now want my secondary blog to be my personal or my main blog. So that as soon and I sign on the newer blog I made would be my default blog. If that makes any sense... Is there a ...
  • Response
    Response: basics
    Starting with registering the domain and designing the layout.
  • Response
    Response: visit our website
    How do I become a blogger in the food and drink category?
  • Response
    I have had an online magazine for 3 years, and we are looking to spice up the website. We've used Joomla, but are now looking for something new. Is Wordpress better than Joomla? We will be adding content rich items on the site: videos, etc. Any suggestions?.
  • Response
    I am looking for creative writing training(novel writing), cause you can only teach yourself so much until you need outside help!. . Has anyone had any positive experience with such a service that they would recommend?.
  • Response
    Response: pay day loans
    Can one become a partner on YouTube with copyright content on their page?
  • Response
    Response: terry cloth robes
    I am changing hosting companies and would like to move my WordPress Blogs over. Does anyone know of an easy way to accomplish this?.
  • Response
    What blogging website had the least invasive ads for free-account users?. Or what blogging website is best for someone looking to start a professional literary blog?.
  • Response
    Response: navigate here
    I have my own blog and might bid on projects to blog for others. I believe there are some guidelines out there around what is allowed or not regarding images posted on public blogs (such as copyright rules, licensing, or trademarks). Is there anywhere to go to find industry guidelines for ...
  • Response
    I have a Blogger blog that is hooked up to my personal website. The actual blog is linked off of the homepage. I would like to know if there's a widget or something that I can put on my website's homepage that will show my latest blog posts. Not the whole ...
  • Response
    go here for greatest ppc company work around
  • Response
    get greatest prevent arthritis in dogs around
  • Response
    Effectively stated and with glorious timing
  • Response
    Response: la seo
    get greatest que es el seo available
  • Response
    Response: insurance
    Can a computer virus passively infect the computer by just being online?
  • Response
    see here for top quality dog medication available
  • Response
    How can I install WordPress without losing all the indexed html pages?
  • Response
    The top quality dog arthritis pain available
  • Response
    I want to be able to use my gmail account to forward blog posts to people, but for some reason Thunderbird keeps forcing me to use my college e-mail. Is there a way to change this?.
  • Response
    go here for top quality dog arthritis pain around
  • Response
    Response: website
    Want to make people visit a blog and don't know how. Also can you give me a good blogging site that people visit a lot. Do they visit your blog within the blog site or externally?? Thanks..
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    I have been a yahoo users for some years now. I am only starting to make use of the tools which they provide, one of which being blog posts. I have written a blog and would like to know if my blog posts are being seen by others. If not then ...
  • Response
    Response: a forever recovery
    see here for greatest info on alcoholism causes available
  • Response
    Response: Trudy Fischels
    I found a great...
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    Response: dumpsters
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    Response: dumpsters
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    Response: dumpsters
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    Response: ringsidenews.com
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    Response: skdevsolutions.com
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    Response: lottery ticket
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    Response: trang paula rmit
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Tabloid

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>