Recent Film Reviews
Old Film Reviews
Navigation

The new album from Al Rose. Available at CD Baby,  iTunes and Amazon.

If you like the cut of our jib over here at The Moving World, please consider kicking a little something our way.

Journal Archive
« Super 8 | Main | Midnight in Paris »
Monday
Jul162012

Certified Copy

“You play the loving woman, I play the faithful man…”
--Bruce Springsteen, “Brilliant Disguise”

 “There's nothing more cinematic than the sight of a man and a woman talking at 3 a.m. in the dark night of the soul.”
--attributed to Andrew Sarris

This is the first film this year that I’ve had to go back and see a second time at the theater.  It’s Abbas Kiarostami’s first feature made outside of Iran, and he’s got something really fascinating here, something of tremendous emotional power.  It felt very personal to me, as though I were watching the stages of my own failed marriage reflected in the single afternoon that two people spend walking around a little Tuscan village, seeming to morph from strangers into an old married couple before our eyes.

An Englishman named James (William Shimell) has come to Arezzo, Tuscany to talk about his controversial new book, which argues that a good copy of a painting or a sculpture is no less a “real” work of art than the original, if it gives just as much pleasure (and he believes that pleasure is the point of life).  He strikes me as a wise man, wearing lightly his wealth of interesting ideas about art and life.  He meets a Frenchwoman (Binoche), the proprietor of a local shop full of artifacts, sculpture and the like.  She had briefly attended his lecture, and while she bought multiple copies of his book, she makes it clear that his thesis annoys her.  Nonetheless, she is thrilled (and nervous) to be hosting him.

She drives him out to see a little town called Luciagno.  They stop for a cup of coffee.  Now, for some time their conversation has carried overtones which seem just slightly off for banter amongst strangers.  As James steps out to take a call, their elderly hostess strikes up an amusing discussion with Binoche about her “husband.”  Binoche rolls with it, and when her conversation with James resumes we watch, disoriented, as they take on the roles of a married couple who’ve just marked their 15th anniversary, fighting like only people do for whom love itself is at stake.  Are they role-playing?  Part of our disorientation comes from just how intense Binoche is.  No way is she playing a game.  It’s too “real”.  (But of course this is itself just an illusion created by a brilliant actress.)

To what extent do a couple play roles with each other?  James, hungry and fed up with the contentious Binoche, gives himself over to a snit at a trattoria.  The first time I saw it I found that scene curious.  It seems to be the only time in the picture when Shimell (in real life an opera baritone), so natural throughout the rest of the picture, seemed visibly to be acting (that is to say, role-playing).  Seeing it again, it occurred to me that perhaps Kiarostami gave him that direction, as a way to keep the audience guessing.  In any case, I saw myself in James’s peak of pique.  At one point Binoche tells him that she knows he hates her, and maybe in that moment he does.  But later, as he watches her sit down on some steps and rub her sore feet, I recognized that moment, too.  I knew what he was feeling then: remorse, compassion…and love.
 
“Certified Copy” is a film bursting with ideas and feeling.  It’s about the interplay and fluidity, in art and life, of perception, identity, mortality, reproduction, time.  Throughout the movie we see people and things reflected on “screens” such as mirrors and windshields.  If, like James and Binoche in this movie, we would go looking for the original, the “real you” in that hall of mirrors, it is because we know that the original is the one that contains the heart, the heart that—once upon a time, and still—we love.

 
Rating: ***** 

 
Key to ratings:

***** (essential viewing)
**** (excellent)
*** (worth a look)
** (forgettable)
* (rubbish!!)

- June 21, 2011

References (102)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    Response: solde sac lancel
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    Response: Kids Ugg
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    And I HAVE read wordpress support page. Just want to know, if my files over 3GB will be deleted if I will not extend my upgrade for another 12 months..
  • Response
    Response: what is an iva
    What's a good fun blogging site to use with another person?
  • Response
    trying to determine whether my company blog should be housed on corp. website or using different platform like Blogspot? The goal is to drive as much qualified traffic to the "new" corp. website as possible. Also, what would be better from an SEO perspective?.
  • Response
    Response: web search engine
    I'm studying for my bachelors degree in computer science, and I might continue on to get a masters degree. I have my A+ and Network+ certifications, and I'm planning on getting Linux, Network Security, and the Microsoft certifications.. . Can I get a job doing computer forensics with this? If not, ...
  • Response
    How do you protect articles put on a website against copyright infringement?
  • Response
    Response: granuflo lawsuit
    How do I use wordpress and comicpress to create a website and publish my comic strips?
  • Response
    Response: american bullion
    Where can I take a creative writing class in Chicago this summer?
  • Response
    Response: click here now
    Is there a computer program that will automatically start other programs?
  • Response
    How to stop Firefox download window from popping up in Mac?
  • Response
    I am starting a business selling various baby things that I make. And I want to start a website to be able to sell them on. Can anyone tell me the steps that I would need to go through to do this? And what is the cost?. Thanks..
  • Response
    Response: winding up advice
    It seems like the internet is where it's at. I studied Computer Information and Film/Video at school, but I'm not too shabby with a keyboard when it comes to writing interesting stuff. Does anyone know of anyone (aside from Drudge and Arianna Huffington) who has been able to make a few ...
  • Response
    Response: seo services la
    How do I get Firefox not to block the installation of farmville toolbar, Allow did not work?
  • Response
    Response: Michael Honari
    I have one computer running Vista which is connected to the internet and I want to be able to get the internet on my second computer (that's got XP) which is connected via a crossover cable. What do I need to set to be able to surf the net on my ...
  • Response
    Response: rare coin prices
    where is the best site to do a blog,blog tips be grateful. thanks for help. sam i tried get your blog but seems no thread,check it out.
  • Response
    What are the most popular blog sites in the Philippines where I can submit my blogs for others to read?
  • Response
    Response: gold investing
    I am new to web designing and it made me more confused when I stumble into this content-management-system thing. I'm planning to update a site that is not designed using JOOMLA and was wondering if I can use Joomla to update it..
  • Response
    I plan on starting a blog and would eventually like to bring in ad revenue, should I start out on a free website or should I buy a domain?.
  • Response
    How do i make videos bigger in my blogger website larger?
  • Response
    I'm trying to start up a small blog, primarily to hold a few short stories I've written and get feedback, but also for various other blog-type activities. This won't do me any good if I can't get my words where people can read them.. . Blogspot is preferred, but anything allowing ...
  • Response
    I have a site, and my content is protected with a Creative Commons license, but I want to copyright it so places like eBaums World doesn't steal my content. How can I get my entire site copyrighted?.
  • Response
    Response: check out here
    How to transfer my blog from blogspot to paid hosting?
  • Response
    Response: his explanation
    I would like to be a creative writing professor, but I can no find out exactly what they do. I love to write, and to help other people become better writers, so that is why I want to become a creative writing/english professor. Does this fit with the profession? What is ...
  • Response
    Response: homeowners
    I have my own blog and might bid on projects to blog for others. I believe there are some guidelines out there around what is allowed or not regarding images posted on public blogs (such as copyright rules, licensing, or trademarks). Is there anywhere to go to find industry guidelines for ...
  • Response
    Response: Plumber
    Can i upload short excerpts of copyrighted content on youtube?Is it supported by fair use provision?
  • Response
    Response: image source
    I have been wanting to start a successful blog i want to start a blogg useing the best free blogg starting website .... pleez tell me which one is the best??????\.
  • Response
    I have two computers: I call one the "good" computer -- it has two monitors. The other is my "junk" computer with one screen where I download a lot of stuff to it.. . If I wanted to continue using both computers but only with the dual monitors, what would I ...
  • Response
    Response: find more info
    Where are some good places to get good free blogger templates?. I know of pyzam but I would like to search others, what are some good sites?.
  • Response
    How do I edit a wordpress page to display only the posts, so minus the menubars?
  • Response
    Response: total stranger
    I have created a blog using Blogspot, and I want it to appear on Google Search. Can someone provide me with the steps to do so? . . Much appreciated!.
  • Response
    New to joomla please guide me i have download joomla from website ? What should i do ?.
  • Response
    Response: look at these guys
    How to let the other people know about your blogspot?
  • Response
    Response: view
    The template I made doesn't have any code in it about the navbar. I'd like to bring it back. What code do I put in to show the Navbar in blogger?.
  • Response
    Response: explanation
    What is the best way to start a Blog for profit?
  • Response
    How would you start a website to help people that are having problems in there Relationship?
  • Response
    Response: your input here
    What actually is a blog and how do i start one?
  • Response
    How do you copyright content on your site (Webcomic specifically)?
  • Response
    How do I start a blog with payment options for readers?
  • Response
    How do I make my own Blogger layout? I already made a header, I want to learn how to make a matching layout?
  • Response
    I was planning on starting the guide with wordpress..
  • Response
    How do you copyright content on your site (Webcomic specifically)?
  • Response
    Response: insurance
    How to Protect my Internet Articles with a Copyright ?
  • Response
    Response: [source]
    ok so how to do it?. . i have seen people getting their blog posts published on their facebook fan page. pls help . thanks.
  • Response
    I made a few songs and I want to know how to alter the copyright content on an MP3 file so I can share it online? I want to add (p) Swagers Studios (2009) to the copyright content and was wondering if it was possible. Any help is greatly appreciated.. It's ...
  • Response
    Response: view
    I'm creating a collaborative blog and I need to know if I can transform a blogspot blog into one where anyone can add content and edit or change the text. Maybe there is another type of blog whee you can do this.. Thanks everyone..
  • Response
    I have Firefox as my main web browser already, but I want my windows live messenger to open all windows on Firefox and not IE7. For example, the email icon on the top left hand corner of wlm. Every time I click on it, it opens up on IE7 which i ...
  • Response
    Response: their explanation
    I'm finding them for my sister. I'm trying to find the most recipes with pictures and the ages of baby for the recipes. Blogs are usually where I would expect to find them..
  • Response
    I would like to start a blog speaking out against feminism. So I would like to know the best way to do it and the best place to go to start one..
  • Response
    Response: ford f-150
    see here for the best ford explorer around
  • Response
    Response: see here
    The background image of my website is labeled for commercial reuse. However, I need to copyright all other content (since I do not own the image), how do I go about doing so? Just to label my website as copyrighted... I am not concerned with the entire copyrighting process... All help ...
  • Response
    I know that there are countless plug-ins designed to make the comments do-follow, but I'm looking for something that will make the links in the blog-posts themselves do-follow. Please include a link or detailed instructions on how to do this. Thanks!. Do you have any examples of themes that you know ...
  • Response
    Response: they said
    Hi,. I am new to joomla and my boss is asking me to add some of the joomla functionality to the current website so that the owner of the website can itself modify the contents. I am having no idea about how to do that. My boss says that there is ...
  • Response
    Copyright? Can I distribute publically distributed legal articles to my clients without violating copyright?
  • Response
    I want to change my home page to another page with wordpress, is it possible?.
  • Response
    Response: experienced
    Hi,. can enybody please tell me other platforms that blogger, wordpress, posterous, dupral where I can make blog posts by email?. I need a list of free blog services that allow you to make your post by email..
  • Response
    heyas :-). how are you all?. well i love to write and i rele want to get into creative writing and but i have a hard time coming up with ideas on what to write about and was wondering if you knew how i could get over this "writer's block"?. . ...
  • Response
    How can I prevent my blogspot from showing up in search engines?
  • Response
    Response: gold in your ira
    Hi, What is the best free software to automatically backup wordpress database and files ? A software that is trustworthy and would not hack your password in wordpress. Have you tried it ? For How long ? Thanks......
  • Response
    Response: buy gold ira
    Can I copyright 20 pages of old newspaper articles ?
  • Response
    Through Blogger, i have a blog using Blogspot. I would likie to know how to export all my posts from Blogspot to my newly created Weebly blog..
  • Response
    hello everyone. I am planning to start a website with my partner in Australia. But now, later, we get know that a website with the same concept is already exist in UK and they have patent themselves. so does this can cause us a problem. second thing is how we can ...
  • Response
    The top quality symptoms of arthritis in dogs around
  • Response
    When installing Joomla on my computer in order to update a preexisting site, do I need my client to give me the Host Name, MySQL User Name, MySQL Password, MySQL Database NAme and MySQL Table Prefix? I already have their FTP information, and the Joomla admin control panel login information..
  • Response
    I'm into photography and would like to start selling my work and attracting more clients. My question is how would I go about starting a website where people can buy my photos or contact me about taking photos? I'm looking for a way to maximize my advertising and would really like ...
  • Response
    What are the norms of copyright of web content? How's it different from Patent?
  • Response
    Response: seo services
    see here for greatest la seo available
  • Response
    How do I prevent Firefox from opening a site that has a virus?
  • Response
    Response: for consumers
    I want to start my own blog: are there such thing as blogs that are totally "open", and anybody can view it? I keep coming to the kind where you have to add other "friends" to use the site. . Links appreciated. Thanks!.
  • Response
    Response: que es el seo
    get greatest como posicionar una pagina web anywhere
  • Response
    The top quality treatment for arthritis available
  • Response
    I have created a blog using Blogspot, and I want it to appear on Google Search. Can someone provide me with the steps to do so? . . Much appreciated!.
  • Response
    The greatest dog vitamins arthritis for dogs around
  • Response
    I want to create my own website but I have no experience. A classmate recommended me to instead create a blog so that I can get experience. . What free blog site should I use?. Any tips?.
  • Response
    see here for top quality seo web anywhere
  • Response
    see here for greatest dog s arthritis or joint anywhere
  • Response
    get best signs of dog with arthritis anywhere
  • Response
    Response: their website
    I'm wanting to start a blog for my photography business. What free blog would be best?.
  • Response
    I want to start a blog. It seems like blogspot is really popular. Does anyone have another free site that they like where you can make a blog?.
  • Response
    Response: property plus
    I just bought a new computer and would like the same settings I have on my other computer. How do I go about doing this? The one thing I want to change in firefox on my new computer is when I type a website in the address bar I would like ...
  • Response
    Response: property loan
    Without asking them to delete it, is there a way i can delete my own blog comments on someone else's blog? Please help(:.
  • Response
    How to start a blog. Kindly suggest books on the subject?
  • Response
    Any suggestions on sites to start a blog where I can BS sports and another happenings?
  • Response
    I'm trying to find out what the most popular blogs are when it comes to news and views and cell phone stuff..
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    Response: Niagara therapy
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    Response: Leonard McDowall
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    Response: Anthony Alles
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    Response: Anthony Alles
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    Response: Mark Galliano
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    Response: D D Photographics
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    Response: Anthony Alles
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy
  • Response
    The Moving World - Old Reviews - Certified Copy

Reader Comments (1)

We finally saw "Certified Copy" last evening. We are still puzzling over the meaning of the film, and as you say, the director may like it that way. We were surprised when it ended so abruptly as we were still waiting for clarification on the nature of the relatioship. Perhaps we'll need to see it a second time too as you found necessary.

January 21, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterBarbara Pfeiffer

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>